Underfloor insulation is one of the more worthwhile retrofits in an older house, and one of the few that a determined owner can do without opening a wall. It is also a job with a bad safety record when it is done carelessly. The sequence is the thing: look first, fix what you find, lay the moisture barrier, then insulate.
BRANZ research cited in its Level guide indicates that 830,000 New Zealand houses do not have insulation meeting what is required of new homes today. Almost one-fifth have less than 80 per cent coverage of subfloor areas. Level's view is that insulation can be added fairly easily under timber-framed floors in most houses, unlike in walls, and that ceiling insulation should come first when heat loss is being tackled.
For rental homes it is not optional. Tenancy Services says ceiling and underfloor insulation is compulsory in all rental homes, and BRANZ notes that thermal insulation is required in suspended floors where it is reasonably practicable to install it. Landlords who miss their obligations under the healthy homes standards may face penalties of up to $7,200.
Before buying a roll of anything, spend an hour under the house with a torch and a camera. Look for:
A polythene ground sheet reduces moisture rising into the subfloor. Under the Building Act's Schedule 1, installing a ground moisture barrier in an existing building's subfloor space is exempt from building consent. For rentals with an enclosed subfloor, Tenancy Services says a barrier must be installed if it is possible to do so, either as polythene installed in accordance with section 8 of NZS 4246:2016, or with a vapour flow resistance of at least 50 MNs/g installed by a professional. It can be installed by the house owner or a building professional.
BRANZ's guidance on floors covers the options:
Installation standards matter: NZS 4246:2016 sets out how to install bulk thermal insulation in houses, and it is referenced in the Acceptable Solution H1/AS1. Level adds that gaps are costly. A 16 millimetre gap around the edge of ceiling insulation can cut its R-value by almost half, and compressing a blanket reduces its R-value too.
This is the part that deserves emphasis. Level reports that retrofitting foil insulation under houses has been banned since 1 July 2016, and that installers using metal staples to fix foil have sometimes pierced a live cable. There have been five electrocution deaths and one non-fatal shock in New Zealand. Level also advises taking extreme care where electrical cables run under the floor, and keeping polystyrene separated from PVC-sheathed cables, because over time the cable sheathing becomes brittle where the two stay in contact.
Practical consequences:
Electrical work itself is for authorised people; see the Electricity Act's restrictions on prescribed electrical work.
Tenancy Services gives the healthy homes minimum for underfloor insulation as R1.3 across the climate zones for properties that received building consent before 3 November 2022. Tenancy Services notes that new builds and renovations needing consent must meet the 2021 Building Code update, which exceeds the healthy homes figures. Retrofitting existing insulation or topping it up does not trigger the Code requirement unless the property is undergoing renovations that need consent. Existing insulation must also be in reasonable condition, with no mould, dampness, damage or gaps.
Schedule 1 of the Building Act lists installing thermal insulation in an existing building as exempt from consent, other than in an external wall or an internal fire separation wall. Level adds that retrofitting wall insulation requires a consent unless the council has made an exemption. The exemption is still conditional, so read it on legislation.govt.nz.
Insulating last under the floor, rather than first, avoids contractors trampling and tearing it.
Standards, R-value tables and healthy homes requirements are updated, so confirm current figures with Tenancy Services or EECA before you buy materials.