THE RENO LEDGER
ENTRY · 22.11.2026

Budgeting a renovation and setting contingencies

A renovation budget is a forecast about things you cannot see. In a newer house that is a small risk. In an older one the unknowns are built in: rot behind a bathroom wall, wiring nobody documented, paint and linings that need testing before anyone touches them. A budget that ignores this is a wish list.

Why old houses blow budgets

Consumer NZ's guide to the building process says it plainly: surprises often turn up on day one or soon after, usually uncovering rot, dampness or dodgy building practices from the past. For the job to continue, and for the family to be safe in the house afterwards, these need repairing. The changes are known as variations, they probably are not in the original contract, and you pay for the extra materials and the builder's time. Its advice is to have a contingency fund set aside.

The same guide says what to do about the changes themselves: instruct the builder in writing about every variation to the specified work, and get a written costing. Note that a change may also mean amending the building consent.

Estimates, quotes and contracts are different things

MBIE's guide to rights for homeowners separates them. A quote is based on detailed specifications and is the price you will pay to complete the work, except for matters outside the builder's reasonable control and extra cost from agreed variations. An estimate is a looser figure. And a quote is not a contract: quotes typically lack the detail of a contract and may not say how variations and disputes are handled.

Some practical consequences follow from that guide:

Provisional sums and prime cost sums

Two items on a quote deserve a second look. MBIE explains that contingency or PC sums may be either of two things. A provisional sum sets money aside for specific work where there is not enough detail for a fixed price, such as when an item has not been chosen and installation cost is unknown. Ask the contractor to confirm the amount will be adequate for the quality you expect.

A prime cost sum sets aside a fixed amount for an item you will choose yourself, such as a kitchen sink. If you pick something that costs more, you pay the difference, and the sum does not include installation. A quote with generous allowances for tapware and tiles can look cheaper than one that has priced them realistically, so compare the allowances as closely as the totals.

Where to put the contingency

Neither source gives a percentage for a contingency fund, and a number from an unrelated blog would be a guess. A better approach is to build one from the particular house:

  1. List what is concealed: bathroom floors and walls, subfloor, roof framing, old wiring, old plumbing.
  2. For each, ask what is the plausible worst case, and who would be doing the repair.
  3. Add the cost of testing and safe handling for anything pre-1980 that might contain lead paint or asbestos. Auckland Council notes asbestos was widely used in building materials from the 1940s to the mid-1980s, and that suspect materials should be tested by a professional; Health NZ says lead paint is the main source of lead exposure in houses built before about 1970.
  4. Set the contingency against that list, and keep it separate from the main budget so it is not spent on upgrades.

A quantity surveyor can help here. MBIE notes that, working from your plans, a QS can give a reasonable idea of the costs of the work, and can also calculate progress payments and cost variations during construction.

The things people forget

Order the spending

Money goes furthest when the work is sequenced to find problems early. Open up the concealed areas first, before ordering fittings or finalising finishes, so surprises land while you still have choices to scale back. Structure, weathertightness, wiring and plumbing come before linings and finishes, and decorative items come last.

If the quote comes in over budget, cut scope or finishes. Do not cut the contingency. It is the only item on the list designed to be spent, and a renovation of an old house is certain to need it.

Sources

SEE ALSO: Making good old floorboards before you sand and finish; Lead paint and renovations; Lead dust and keeping the household safe
The Reno Ledger records what is worth knowing before and during the renovation of an older New Zealand house. General information; check consent rules with your council.