THE RENO LEDGER
ENTRY · 22.11.2026

Making good old floorboards before you sand and finish

Original timber floors are one of the best things about an older house, and one of the easiest to get wrong. Sanding is the glamorous step, but it comes near the end. What comes first is working out why the boards look the way they do, and whether anything in or on them is hazardous to disturb.

Read the boards first

Spend an evening on your knees with a torch and a screwdriver. Small round holes of about 2 to 4 millimetres and little piles of fine dust point to common house borer, according to Consumer NZ. Larger oval holes, up to about 7 millimetres, belong to the native two-toothed longhorn, which is less likely to be in a building and tends to cause heavier damage.

Patchiness is normal. Borer prefers soft sapwood and untreated timber, so it is common to find some boards peppered with holes while the boards beside them are untouched. Those untouched boards are probably denser heartwood. Old holes may also be long finished: a hole shows where an adult left, not that a larva is still feeding. A specialist can tell you whether activity is current, which a torch cannot.

Press the screwdriver into the worst boards, and into the joists and bearers beneath them if you can reach from the subfloor. Boards that crumble, flex or will not hold a nail need replacing. Boards that are merely holey are a cosmetic question.

Find the damp

Borer likes damp wood, and Consumer NZ notes that floor timbers are prone to damp. If you find a patch of damaged boards, look under it. Blocked vents, a leaking pipe, or soil piled against the foundations will all keep the timber wet. No treatment lasts if the cause stays.

Treat before you finish

The only long-term treatment Consumer NZ describes is a residual surface application of an insecticide or preservative, one that outlasts the borer's life cycle. It only works on bare timber, which is why this is a sanding-stage job: you may need to strip paint or varnish first. Fogging and similar airborne treatments kill adults on the wing between November and March but do not stop larvae working inside the wood. Female borer lay eggs on bare timber or in old borer holes, so a freshly sanded floor with no protection is a welcoming surface.

Large infestations should go to a professional with the right safety equipment. If the aim is neat boards, filling borer holes is a cosmetic step that follows treatment and repair, not a substitute for them, and an inspector can advise whether holes are old or still active before you fill anything.

Lead paint comes before the sander

Painted boards, borders around a carpet square and skirting boards in a house painted before 1980 may carry lead-based paint. Health NZ says you cannot tell by looking, and that a hardware-store test kit can help; if you cannot test, assume pre-1980 paint may contain lead. Its guidance on removing lead-based paint calls wet sanding and scraping the preferred methods and says dry sanding by hand or machine is not recommended because of the dust it creates.

If a floor has been painted rather than varnished, take that seriously. Machine sanders produce a great deal of fine dust, and young children and pregnant women are the people most at risk from lead dust. Keep them out of the house while the work is on, cover or remove soft furnishings, and use a vacuum with a HEPA filter for clean-up. A bare timber floor under old varnish is a different question from boards under decades of paint, so test the paint, not the floor.

Replacing boards

When a board has to go, replace as little as you can and match what is there in species, width and thickness, so the floor reads as one surface once it is sanded. Cut damaged lengths back to a joist rather than patching mid-span, and stagger the joins.

Any replacement timber still needs the same attention as the original. Fit it, then treat all newly exposed surfaces and the ends of cut boards while they are bare.

Consent and who does the work

Replacing a few floorboards in the same position with comparable boards is the sort of repair MBIE's guidance on work that does not need a consent describes as general repair and maintenance with comparable materials. The exemption does not cover complete or substantial replacement of anything contributing to structural behaviour, and floors can be structural. If you are touching joists, bearers or the floor frame, check with the council and consider a licensed building practitioner. Retrofitting insulation beneath a floor is a separate exempt item in the same guidance, but external wall insulation is not, so keep the two jobs apart in your planning.

Order of work

  1. Test paint for lead and plan for dust control.
  2. Fix moisture and ventilation under the floor.
  3. Replace unsound boards and any damaged joists.
  4. Strip or sand with wet or dust-controlled methods, to bare timber.
  5. Treat for borer on bare wood.
  6. Fill holes where you want a smoother look, then seal or finish.
  7. Do the underfloor insulation at the end of the subfloor work, once repairs are finished.

Treating a floor properly is more about sequence than skill. Get it right and the boards will look better in ten years than the day you finish. Get the sequence wrong and you risk spreading lead dust through the house, or sealing borer in under a new coat of finish.

For written assurance on a floor you plan to keep, a report from a firm such as Lignum Timber Inspections records what was found and when.

Sources

SEE ALSO: Bathroom renovations and waterproofing; Asbestos in older houses: where it hides
The Reno Ledger records what is worth knowing before and during the renovation of an older New Zealand house. General information; check consent rules with your council.