Old houses are full of timber that has been quietly feeding insects for decades, and the first question on opening up a wall or floor is usually whether the chewed wood can stay. The answer is rarely all or nothing. Most borer damage is a question of degree, and the order in which you deal with it matters as much as the carpentry itself.
Consumer NZ puts the choice plainly: minor or early infestation can be treated in place, severely weakened timber should be strengthened, and timber that is badly affected may ultimately need to be replaced. A flight hole or two in a floorboard is a different problem from a bearer you can push a screwdriver into.
Common house borer is the species most owners meet. Its flight holes are small, around 2 to 4 millimetres, and it leaves fine sawdust, called frass. It favours soft sapwood and untreated timber, which is why it is not unusual for some boards in a floor to be riddled while their neighbours are untouched. The untouched ones are probably harder heartwood. That is useful when you are judging how much to remove: damage tends to be patchy and follows the sapwood.
Knowing what is wrong with a member is the first step to deciding whether to cut it out, and a specialist assessment of borer damage repair options can help when the extent is unclear or the timber is structural.
The two-toothed longhorn borer is a native species with larger, oval flight holes of up to about 7 millimetres. Consumer NZ notes it can stay in the wood for up to 11 years before emerging in autumn, that its damage is usually severe, and that the affected timber will often have to be replaced. It is more common in bush-clad areas and is less likely to turn up in buildings than common house borer, but if you find the larger holes, assume replacement is more likely than treatment.
Borer likes damp timber, so replacing a bearer without finding out why it was damp simply sets up the next round. Floor timbers and the south side of a building are prone to dampness, and Consumer NZ advises keeping the underfloor space well ventilated. Look for blocked vents, soil banked above floor level, and leaking pipes before you order any timber.
New timber should also be chosen for the job. Consumer NZ points out that some woods are naturally resistant, macrocarpa being one example, and that kiln-dried radiata pine resists borer better, provided it stays dry. For piles, the Building Code Acceptable Solution requires timber treated to at least H5. Sawn timber is more prone to attack than a smooth surface. Check the intended use with the timber retailer rather than assuming a treated piece is suitable for every position.
Replacing damaged timber is often exempt from building consent, but only up to a point. MBIE's guidance on building work that does not need a consent says the exemption for general repair, maintenance and replacement covers like-for-like work: comparable materials, and replacement in the same position. Its own example is replacing rotten wooden piles with new treated piles in the same positions, provided the work is not a complete or substantial replacement.
The limits are worth reading closely. The exemption does not cover complete or substantial replacement of a component that contributes to the building's structural behaviour, and it does not cover repairs to something that has failed its Building Code durability requirement. MBIE's examples of work that does need consent include replacing wall cladding that failed within 15 years of installation and damaged the framing. If you are not sure, the guidance suggests asking the council for a discretionary exemption or applying for a consent rather than risking applying the exemption incorrectly.
All building work, consented or not, must still meet the Building Code.
Restricted building work is work involving primary structure or weathertightness, and it must be done or supervised by a licensed building practitioner. MBIE's homeowner guide describes primary structure as work contributing to resistance of vertical and horizontal loads, such as walls, foundations, floors and roofs. Replacing a rotten bearer or stud can fall inside that definition, so ask the council or a designer whether your job counts before you hand it to a handyman. The practitioner register lets you confirm someone's licence, and the guide suggests asking to see their identification.
A licensed practitioner or a specialist can also tell you whether a repair is cosmetic or structural, which matters for how much weight to put on the finished job. A written report from a firm such as Lignum Timber Inspections is also worth keeping on file for when you sell.
Stripping old paint in a house built before about 1980 raises a separate issue, since the paint may contain lead. Health NZ's guidance on safely removing lead-based paint recommends wet methods and keeping children and pregnant women away, and it does not recommend dry sanding.
Borer has a long life cycle. Larvae can feed for up to four years, and adults fly for about a month between November and March, so a treated house is not insect-free overnight. Treat the repair as a package of moisture control, replacement and surface protection rather than a single job.